Showing posts with label Syro-Aramaic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Syro-Aramaic. Show all posts

Friday, December 19, 2014

"Seven lampstands of the Divine Light"

I enjoy how the colors, symbols, and images of light surrounding Hanukkah seem to go hand-in-hand with Christmas. My own spiritual tradition is not quickly learned nor easily understood (even by those in it) so it was a delightful surprise to discover that in Hanukkah a connection between Judaism and Christianity still lives.

Judaism remembers the reclaiming of its most holy place and the miracle of the unfailing light at the temple's re-dedication. One day's supply of holy oil miraculously lasted eight days. Thus the Festival of Lights was born. While Christianity celebrates the same set of historic events on its ancient calendar, it has focused on the martyrdoms which preceded the temple's recapture, i.e. the ultimate sacrifice of those who refused to compromise the temple's sanctity.  Judaism’s Hanukkah and the Christian veneration of the Holy Maccabeans are rare instances where the two religions (on different days of the year) memorialize the same martyrs.

The Old Testament book of II Maccabees recounts the story of the desecration of the Jewish temple around the year 165 BCE by the forces of Antiochus IV Epiphanes. Chapter six lists how the Greeks mobbed their way into the temple, interrupted, and overran the holy places:

For the temple was filled with debauchery and reveling by the Gentiles, who dallied with harlots and had intercourse with women within the sacred precincts, and besides brought in things for sacrifice that were unfit. The altar was covered with abominable offerings which were forbidden by the laws. A man could neither keep the sabbath, nor observe the feasts of his fathers, nor so much as confess himself to be a Jew. (II Maccabees 6:4-6)

The Greeks attempted to force the Jews to pay homage to the conquerors' religion and those who refused to comply were killed. As is common with political reformers, it didn't matter to the Greeks whether or not the Jews actually believed in the Hellenistic pantheon. What was important was that they made the religious opposition cry "Uncle". Chapter six continues:

On the monthly celebration of the king’s birthday, the Jews were taken, under bitter constraint, to partake of the sacrifices; and when the feast of Dionysus came, they were compelled to walk in the procession in honor of Dionysus, wearing wreaths of ivy. At the suggestion of Ptolemy a decree was issued to the neighboring Greek cities, that they should adopt the same policy toward the Jews and make them partake of the sacrifices, and should slay those who did not choose to change over to Greek customs. (II Maccabees 6:7-9)


The ancient Christian Church remembers the names of nine martyrs: Habim, Antonin, Guriah, Eleazar, Eusebon, Hadim, Marcellus, their mother Salomonia, and their venerable teacher Eleazar.  The Jewish tradition on the other hand has passes down by name only one personality- the scribe and elder Eleazar. II Maccabees gives us a touching account of Eleazar's defiance:

Elea′zar, one of the scribes in high position, a man now advanced in age and of noble presence, was being forced to open his mouth to eat swine’s flesh. But he, welcoming death with honor rather than life with pollution, went up to the the rack of his own accord, spitting out the flesh, as men ought to go who have the courage to refuse things that it is not right to taste, even for the natural love of life.

"...by manfully giving up my life now, [says Eleazar] I will show myself worthy of my old age and leave to the young a noble example of how to die a good death willingly and nobly for the revered and holy laws.” When he had said this, he went at once to the rack. ...So in this way he died, leaving in his death an example of nobility and a memorial of courage, not only to the young but to the great body of his nation. (II Maccabees 6:18-31)

The martyrdoms of the seven brothers and their mother Solomonia are recounted in the next chapter. Eleazar's example then inspired a popular uprising led by by Judas Maccabeus. The temple was eventually retaken, ritually cleansed, and rededicated. Such a heroic event not only warranted its own holiday but also took on messianic significance. It was at this re-dedication that the miracle of the menorah light took place. We know that Christ himself participated in the "Hanakkuh" celebration of His time almost 200 years later:

It was the feast of the Dedication at Jerusalem; it was winter, and Jesus was walking in the temple, in the portico of Solomon... (John 10:22-23)
(By the way, I think it is no coincidence that His "My sheep hear my voice" discussion occurs in the context of temple worship). Scholars have tried to unravel whether the martyrs’ shrines were located in churches or synagogues and on which religious calendar they were celebrated but in the process it became apparent that we are getting a glimpse into a shadowy and long lost the era when the boundaries between the two religions were more fluid.

The mother Salomonia becomes an even more important if cryptic figure when we take into account the various renditions of her name. It would be tempting to assume her name derives from the Jewish root word שלם SHLM meaning "peace", as in the case of the New Testament girl Salome. The late Semitics scholar Julian Obermann (1888–1956) helped tie together the variations of her name:

Catholic and Orthodox:  Salomonia, Salomona, Salomonis, Samona
Syro-Aramaic: Shamuni, Shmuni
Rabbinical souces: Miryam, Hanna
Hebrew: Hashmonith

Obermann suggests her name is actually a reference to the Hasmonean dynasty in which she held a place of honor. Therefore within the Christian name of the mother lies hidden the Jewish dynasty of the times.

We know these martyrs continued to be venerated by the early Christians. The earliest proof of their veneration is from the mid-300s. Their feast day on the 1st of August is known as the "Festival of Shamuni and Her Sons" and is recorded in a Syro-Aramaic martyrology from the Antiochian Church:

 
bnai d'shmuni
"sons of Shamuni"

h'noon d'ktibin b'makabiyeh
"they who were written of in the Maccabees"


The Maccabean Martyrs are later given a place of high honor among the saints by Church Fathers Gregory of Nanzianus and John Chrystostom.

Out of all the Old Testament "righteous" people, why did the Church maintain a festival to the Maccabees alone in the same fashion as later Christian martyrs? This questions was posed to Bernard, the 12th century Abbot of Clairvaux. He wrote a touching response. He replies in part:
Therefore, though the motive makes martyrdom, yet the time and the nature of it determine the difference between martyrdoms. Thus the time in which they lived separates the Maccabees from the martyrs of the new law and joins them with those of the old; but the nature of their martyrdom associates them with the new and divides them from the old. From these causes come the differences of observance with which they are kept in memory in the Church. But that which is common to the whole company of the Saints before God is what the holy prophet declares: Precious in the sight of the Lord is the death of His saints (Ps. 116:15)

There are two things, as it seems to me, which make death precious, the life which precedes it and the cause for which it is endured; but more the cause than the life. But when both the cause and the life concur that is the most precious of all.
Though the Christian focus is on the martyrs, the symbolism of light has not been lost. On August 1st the Orthodox Church still sings the following hymns (called Troparion and Kontakion) in memory of the Maccabean Martyrs

Let us praise the seven Maccabees,
with their mother Solomonia and their teacher Eleazar;
they were splendid in lawful contest
as guardians of the teachings of the Law.
Now as Christ’s holy martyrs they ceaselessly intercede for the world.


Seven pillars of the Wisdom of God
and seven lampstands of the divine Light,
all-wise Maccabees, greatest of the martyrs before the time of the martyrs,
with them ask the God of all to save those who honor you.

The "Seven" are the sons, remembered as children. Salomonia and Eleazar make nine- completing the total number of lights found on the menorah. A Christian icon of the Seven Maccabean Martyrs can be seen here:
    http://www.uncutmountainsupply.com/proddetail.asp?prod=1MA02

Sources (I really don't care about formatting right now.):
  • - Margaret Schatkin "The Maccabean Martyrs" Vigilae Christianae 28, 1974, pp. 97 - 113.
  • - Julian Oberman "The Sepulchre of the Maccabean Martyrs" Journal of Biblical Literature, vol 50 No 4, 1931, pp.250 - 265.
  • - William Wright "An Ancient Syrian Martyrology" The Journal of Sacred Literature vol 8 1866.
  • - II Maccabees, Revised Standard Version Catholic Edition (RSVCE) http://www.biblegateway.com
  • - Bernard of Clairvaux "LETTER XLIV: Concerning the Maccabees" Some Letters of Saint Bernard, Abbot of Clairvaux http://www.ccel.org/ccel/bernard/letters.xlvii.html
  • - Thomas Purcell, Orthodox Menologion for Windows
One of the best resources for understanding the historic and modern connection of Judaism, see the Facebook page of maven Av Aleksandr Avraham.

Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Christ speaks to the Magi

[Magi update: Note that in chapter 29, it becomes necessary for the Magi's experience to be validated through their contact with an apostolic figure and through participation in recognizable Christian worship. If the appended, 3rd person story treats Christ in a different manner than the original, then is it possible the addition also refers to the Magi with different terminology?   Read full article here]

After blogging about a book I try to leave the topic and allow others to do their own exploring without ongoing commentary from me. However the Revelation of the Magi is making quite a splash. Patheos.com invited readers to submit questions, to which Dr. Landau responded on the Patheos blog. Within this exchange Dr. Landau identifies what is considered to be "the most pivotal verse in the entire text" in Revelation of the Magi. Christ says the following to the Magi:

And I am everywhere, because I am a ray of light whose light has shone in this world from the majesty of my Father, who has sent me to fulfill everything that was spoken about me in the entire world and in every land by unspeakable mysteries, and to accomplish the commandment of my glorious Father, who by the prophets preached about me to the contentious house, in the same way as for you, as befits your faith, it was revealed to you about me.

Indeed this is beautiful. I feel we will learn more about this portrayal of Christ as time gives us a chance to contemplate where this fits within ancient Christian literature and discover possible parallels with other texts. Until then we can watch RevMagi's journey unfold as popular culture becomes aware of this ancient narrative:

USA Today article

Radio interview with Brent Landau

Landau writes for Huffington Post

Perhaps Landau will present at the North American Syriac Symposium at Duke University in June? Finally, here is some independent research on the Magi...


Did the Magi wear mullets???

Saturday, November 20, 2010

Syriac scholar Brent Landau and "The Revelation of the Magi"


Oklahoma has been hiding one of its most interesting secrets for two years, namely its very own Syriac scholar. Dr. Brent Landau, graduate of Harvard Divinity School, is Assistant Professor at University of Oklahoma's Religious Studies Program.

Dr. Landau is noted for providing the first English translation of what has been named the "Revelation of the Magi", a Christian apocryphal work and the most extensive Magi account from the ancient world. The Syriac narrative is preserved in a longer work comprising Vaticanus Syriacus 162, a codex housed in the Vatican Library.

Landau estimates the original "Revelation of the Magi" (ROM) was composed in the late second or early third century and was written from the perspective of the Magi themselves. It was then redacted in the third or fourth century to include the Apostle Thomas in a third-person account. The Vatican manuscript used by Landau for his English translation is from the 8th century.

With the Nativity approaching it is no accident that Harper Collins has released Landau's research entitled Revelation of the Magi: The Lost Tale of the Wise Men’s Journey to Bethlehem, based on his dissertation and edited for the wider audience in mind. The press releases and articles begin with the usual dramatic titles about lost scrolls and Christian origins. My favorite is...


This ancient text sheds light on an aspect of the Nativity often taken for granted. Yet the ROM in no way stamps "solved" upon the story of the Wise Men. Just the opposite, it (happily for bibliophiles) raises more questions and suggests relationships with early Christian hymnody and other sources.

ROM is well-crafted and the narrative includes some intriguing points of interest such as; the Magi never refer to Christ by name, their food supplied by Providence appears to have hallucinogenic qualities (or at least that is how it might be described in modern terms), and the original author linguistically equates the Wise Men's title "Magi" with "silent prayer" in some unknown language.

Among the more surprising aspects is the notion that the star of Bethlehem followed by the Magi is far more than an astronomical event. Landau points out the star is actually the pre-existent Christ himself, "a literal representation of St. John's 'light of the world'”. The Johannine connection is certainly a strong one from our 21st century point of view. But when we also take into account the magi/silent prayer connection, the star-as-Christ motif seems to imply that the account is more than just legend and perhaps set within a larger theological context.

Landau recognizes within ROM similarities with Syriac baptismal hymns. I wonder if more light can be shed on these mysterious aspects if it were compared to other existing liturgical material. I cannot immediately recall if the Magi are mentioned in On the Mother of God by Jacob of Serug (trans. Mary Hansbury). If so, it might prove to be an interesting comparison.


If you are interested in seeing the Syriac text (nicely vocalized) and a more technical treatment of the ROM, Landau's dissertation can be downloaded here at Academia.com.


A critical edition will be available to the scholarly community when Landau publishes the Syriac text as part of Brepol's Corpus Christianorum Series Apocryphorum.

What does ROM's complex portrayal of the Wise Men tell us about early Christianity or at least about the Nativity itself? The appearance of the star-Child to the Magi is a clear statement of Christ's ability to reveal Himself to whomever He chooses. In other words, evangelization by humans is not always a necessary endeavor. ROM suggests the possibility that this revelation may be "but one of potentially many instances in which Christ has appeared to the people of the world". Indeed this is supported by the Acts of the Apostles. Beyond this, Landau proposes a more universal message, that the "revelatory activity of Christ as the primal cause of humanity’s religious difference." In other words, Christ could reveal himself in the person of Buddha, Mohammed, or as any religious identity.

Even with ROM's atypical treatment of Christ, the concept of a revelation within other religions brought to mind the ancient and ubiquitous "Christ Pantokrator" icon which, like all icons, communicated Christian belief through visual imagery. Not necessarily a triumphalist symbol, Christ Pantokrator suggests that the various religious traditions are echoes of the truth, and Christ, with His unending love for all humankind will at any time abruptly appear in time and space to anyone for the purpose of affirming His identity, as opposed to equating it to all other iconic identities within the world's religious milieu. A traditional perspective doesn't necessitate that other religions are always antagonistic.

Though the message of the Magi as presented by Brent Landau is more ecumenical than many traditional Christians would be comfortable with, he treats conservative Christian beliefs with great respect and sensitivity both on paper and in person. I hope Brent Landau's expertise will be valued and sought out in a state where Christianity is so predominant.

I generally do not purchase pop culture books written by biblical scholars. But in this case I made an exception and was happy to do so, and for several reasons: it is a work by a recognized Syriac scholar in Oklahoma (the only one) and as an Oklahoman, I am intensely proud of this. Secondly, one gets the impression that the full value of ROM is yet to be discovered. The real story of the Magi will continue to unfold.